In this guide

A white-robed congregation gathered on a hillside in rural Pennsylvania in the summer of 1936. They had no minister, no pulpit, no collection plate. What they had was a shared conviction that the Gospels had been corrupted by Rome and that the true teachings of Jesus could be recovered through direct communion with the dead. The Essene Community Church of Christ was a short-lived but influential American religious movement that blended Spiritualism, Christian mysticism, and a romanticized vision of the ancient Essenes into a single esoteric practice. Founded by former Methodist minister John Ballou Newbrough in the 1880s and later reorganized by his followers, the church claimed to restore the “original” Christianity practiced by Jesus and his disciples before the institutional church suppressed it.

What Was the Essene Community Church of Christ?

What Was the Essene Community Church of Christ

The Essene Community Church of Christ was an esoteric Christian denomination organized in the late 19th century by followers of John Ballou Newbrough (1828–1891), a Spiritualist medium and former Methodist minister. The church taught that Jesus had been an Essene initiate, that the Bible was a symbolic text requiring esoteric interpretation, and that direct communication with spirits was both possible and essential for spiritual growth. It operated primarily in Pennsylvania and Ohio between 1884 and roughly 1910, with a brief revival in the 1930s.

The church’s name reveals its three central commitments: the Essene lineage (a Jewish ascetic sect from the Second Temple period), the communal structure (modeled on early Christian communities), and the Christ-centered theology (reinterpreted through Spiritualist lenses). It never numbered more than a few hundred members, but its influence rippled through later American esoteric movements, including the Liberal Catholic Church and various New Thought denominations. For a broader view of related traditions, see our guide to American esoteric Christianity.

Where Did the Essene Community Church Come From?

Where Did the Essene Community Church Come From

The church’s origins trace directly to John Ballou Newbrough, a man whose life reads like a catalog of 19th-century American religious experimentation. Born in 1828 in Ohio, Newbrough trained as a dentist, practiced Spiritualism, studied Swedenborgian theology, and served as a Methodist minister before breaking with mainstream Christianity. In 1881, he published Oahspe: A New Bible, which he claimed had been dictated to him by spirits while he was in a trance state.

Oahspe is a sprawling text of over 800 pages, mixing elements of Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Spiritualism, and Christian esotericism. It describes a cosmic history of the Earth, the evolution of human souls, and a detailed account of the “Essene Brotherhood” that Jesus supposedly joined at age twelve. Newbrough taught that the Essenes were not merely a historical Jewish sect but a secret order that preserved the true spiritual knowledge of humanity, passed down from ancient Atlantis.

In 1884, Newbrough and a small group of followers established the first Essene Community Church of Christ in Silver Lake, Pennsylvania. The community practiced celibacy, vegetarianism, and communal ownership of property. They held services that included spirit communication, healing rituals, and readings from Oahspe alongside selected Gospel passages. Newbrough served as the church’s “Seer” until his death in 1891.

After Newbrough’s death, the church fractured. One faction remained in Pennsylvania and continued under Mary M. D. Smith, who claimed to receive continued spirit communications. Another group relocated to Ohio and established a separate community near Toledo. Neither group survived past 1915. A third revival occurred in the 1930s when former member James H. Hyslop attempted to reorganize the church, but this effort collapsed with Hyslop’s death in 1939.

What Did the Essene Community Church Actually Believe?

The church’s theology was a layered hybrid of Spiritualist mediumship, Christian esotericism, and Essene romanticism. At its core was the claim that Jesus had been an Essene initiate who taught a secret doctrine accessible only to those prepared to receive it.

The Essene Jesus

The church taught that Jesus was born into the Essene community, studied under its elders, and was initiated into its highest degrees before beginning his public ministry. His miracles, they argued, were not supernatural acts but demonstrations of spiritual laws that the Essenes had mastered. The resurrection was not a physical event but a spiritual manifestation, a “materialization” of the sort that Spiritualist mediums produced in séances.

Reincarnation and Spirit Communication

Unlike mainstream Christianity, the Essene Community Church taught reincarnation. Souls progressed through multiple lifetimes, each one an opportunity to purify the spirit and draw closer to God. Communication with spirits of the dead was not only possible but encouraged. The church’s services regularly included mediumistic messages from “the other side,” and members were taught to develop their own clairvoyant abilities. For definitions of key Spiritualist practices, visit our glossary of Spiritualist terms.

The Bible as Symbol

The church rejected biblical literalism. The Gospels, they taught, were symbolic texts whose true meaning had been hidden by the early church. The virgin birth, the miracles, the ascension: all were allegories for spiritual processes. Oahspe was presented as the key that unlocked these symbols, providing the esoteric framework that the original Essene Jesus had intended.

Communal Living

The church practiced a form of Christian communism modeled on the early Jerusalem church described in the Book of Acts. Members shared their possessions, ate common meals, and submitted to the authority of the community’s “Seer” (Newbrough, and later Smith). This was not optional. The church taught that private property was a spiritual impediment, a remnant of the “fallen” state of humanity.

How Did the Church Practice Its Faith?

The Essene Community Church of Christ met in private homes or rented halls, never in dedicated church buildings. Services were informal by 19th-century standards, lasting two to three hours and including several distinct elements.

The Order of Service

A typical Sunday gathering began with readings from Oahspe and selected Gospel passages. The community’s “Seer” or a designated reader would then offer an interpretation, often delivered in a trance state. This was followed by a period of silent meditation, during which members attempted to receive spirit communications. Any member who felt moved could share a message, which the Seer would authenticate or reject.

Healing was a regular feature. Members would lay hands on the sick while reciting passages from Oahspe and invoking the names of spirits. The church claimed numerous healings, though no independent records survive to verify them.

The Festivals

The church observed the traditional Christian calendar but reinterpreted its festivals. Christmas was celebrated as the birth of the “Christ principle” in each soul, not the historical birth of Jesus. Easter marked the soul’s liberation from the cycle of reincarnation. Pentecost was the most important festival, commemorating the descent of the Holy Spirit as a model for the spirit communication that the church practiced.

The Diet

Vegetarianism was mandatory. Members abstained from meat, alcohol, and tobacco. Some sources suggest that the community also practiced periodic fasting, though the details are unclear. The diet was justified on both spiritual and hygienic grounds: meat was said to “coarsen” the spiritual body and impede mediumistic development.

How Did the Essene Community Church Compare to Other Movements?

The Essene Community Church of Christ was one of several 19th-century American movements that attempted to recover a “primitive” or “original” Christianity. It shared ground with the Latter Day Saints (Mormons), the Shakers, the Oneida Community, and the various Spiritualist churches that proliferated after the Fox sisters’ rappings in 1848.

Similarities to the Latter Day Saints

Both movements claimed new scripture revealed through a prophet. Both taught that the true church had been lost and needed restoration. Both practiced communal living and believed in continuing revelation. The difference was in the source of revelation: Joseph Smith received his from an angel, while Newbrough received his from spirits during trance.

Differences from Mainstream Spiritualism

Most Spiritualist churches of the period were non-creedal and focused almost exclusively on mediumship and spirit communication. The Essene Community Church was more structured, with a defined theology, a sacred text (Oahspe), and a communal discipline that Spiritualist churches typically lacked. It was, in effect, a Spiritualist denomination with a Christian esoteric framework.

The Liberal Catholic Church Connection

The most direct descendant of the Essene Community Church was the Liberal Catholic Church, founded in 1916 by James Ingall Wedgwood and Charles Webster Leadbeater. The Liberal Catholic Church also taught reincarnation, rejected biblical literalism, and incorporated elements of Theosophy. Several former members of the Essene Community Church joined the Liberal Catholic Church after the 1910s, carrying their beliefs into the new movement. For more on related esoteric Christian traditions, explore our guide to gnostic and esoteric Christianity.

What Do People Get Wrong About the Essene Community Church?

The most persistent misconception is that the Essene Community Church of Christ was a direct continuation of the ancient Essene sect. It was not. The church had no historical connection to the Essenes of Qumran. Its “Essene” identity was a romantic reconstruction based on Newbrough’s spirit communications and on 19th-century scholarship that idealized the Essenes as proto-Christians.

A second misconception is that the church was a cult in the modern sense. It was small, authoritarian, and demanding, but it lacked the isolation, the charismatic control, and the abusive practices that define contemporary cults. Members were free to leave, and many did.

A third misconception is that Oahspe is an Essene text. It is not. Oahspe is a 19th-century Spiritualist text that borrows Essene imagery. No ancient Essene manuscript contains anything resembling Newbrough’s cosmology or theology.

FAQ

Was the Essene Community Church of Christ connected to the Dead Sea Scrolls? No. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in 1946, more than fifty years after Newbrough’s death. The church had no knowledge of the actual Essene texts.

Did the church have any famous members? No widely known figures. The church remained small and obscure. Its influence was indirect, through later esoteric Christian movements like the Liberal Catholic Church.

Is the Essene Community Church of Christ still active? No. The last organized congregation dissolved in the late 1930s. However, some individuals and small groups continue to study Oahspe and practice its teachings independently.

What happened to John Ballou Newbrough’s writings? Oahspe remains in print and is available online. It has a small but dedicated readership among esoteric Christians and students of American Spiritualism.

Closing

The Essene Community Church of Christ was a brief experiment in esoteric Christianity, a movement that tried to recover something it believed had been lost. It failed to survive its founder, but its ideas reemerged in later traditions that continue to this day. For those interested in the intersection of Spiritualism and Christian mysticism, the church offers a case study in how 19th-century Americans reimagined the Gospels. Explore our guide to American esoteric Christianity for more on these movements, or visit our glossary of Spiritualist terms for definitions of the practices the church used.